The Drawbacks Of Charcoal Grills
While charcoal grills are popular, they do have a few downsides that should be considered:
- Steep Learning Curve: Learning how to grill using a charcoal grill takes some time, and mistakes are sure to be made.
- Cleaning: Charcoal grills need to be cleaned after every use otherwise there will be a large buildup of ash at the bottom of the grill.
- Long Preheating Time: Generally, charcoal briquettes need to turn grey before being used so that the temperature is more consistent. This can take anywhere from 10 to 20 minutes which is a long preheating time than a pellet grill.
Popular Pellet Grill Brands
Alright, there are a lot of new pellet grill brands, but here are the most popular. Trager is the original pellet grill and has been selling pellet grills for decades. Z Grills is another popular brand that is well known for offering amazing grills at very low prices. Other brands include Rec Tec, Yoder, Mak Grills, and Pit Boss.
There are brands offering well-built grills but are small compared to larger brands like Trager, Z Grills, and Pit Boss are small and other areas of the grill fall behind.
Trager leads the way when it comes to technology and innovation. Z Grills and Pit Boss offer well-built grills at affordable prices.
The Differences Between Pellet And Gas Grills
To identify the type of grill suitable for you, we will have a quick overview of their fundamental differences. While they are both outdoor grills, they are quite different. First, they draw energy from varying sources. The pellet grill uses wood pellets, while the gas grill uses natural gas or propane.
If you intend to throw your meat inside without monitoring it from time to time, the pellet grill could be your choice. It works at a low temperature, which cooks the meat evenly. As a result, the steak or barbeque has a little smoky taste. Pellet grills generally cost more than the gas grill because pellets are not available in many areas compared to the gas.
On the other hand, gas grills cook food faster and impart sear marks on the meat. They create an authentic presentation on the meat for events and parties. Not only that, but they also come in a significant number of burners that can cook large batches of meat at a time. If speed and convenience are your primary consideration, then the gas grill is an excellent choice.
We have created a table to summarize the differences between the gas grills and pellet grills. For a more comprehensive comparison, we also discuss the characteristics of each grill type as well as their brief history and mechanisms on how they work.
We have created a detailed list of differences so you will not miss out on the essential factors that you need to consider.
Read Also: Traeger Steak Temperature
Are Pellet Grills Better Than Gas
Though gas grills and pellet grills are similar in terms of what they can do, you will likely find that one is better for your home and cooking needs. Gas grills are best for those who prefer the natural and full flavor of foods and those who want to use a limited amount of smoke. We also recommend gas grills for home chefs who want to cook quickly.
Pellet grills are better for those who want to save money because they dont require as much fuel as gas grills do. You can also get different bags of wood pellets and experiment with flavor combinations for less than it would cost to buy a single propane tank. We think that pellet grills are better for those who want an intense smoke flavor and those who like slowly roasting and smoking foods.
Difference: Pellet Smoker Vs Gas Grill
First of all, you need to know the difference in this pellet smoker vs. gas grill comparison. To begin with, pellet smokers are grills that use wood pellets as fuel. These are actually very useful since any type of wood can be used.
Maple and alder are the best for pork and meat. Pellet fuel is manufactured from compressed sawdust. Its a pretty neat way to recycle and reuse industrial and agricultural waste. Because of that, they can even cost a lot less than their gas-powered cousins.
As opposed to that, gas grills use propane fuel tanks to heat up the food. Since they use propane, they are cheaper than other gas cooking equipments. However, buying a tank can be very frustrating and costly, and youll even right of gas soon.
However, they give the food texture and heat similar to a gas stove. So youll feel right at home. Gas grills are lesser portable and require to be plugged up to a gas tank all the time. Generally, we would recommend these as they are more effective than electrical grills. But as compared to pellet grills, their texture and taste are way better.
Recommended Reading: How To Clean A Stainless Steel Gas Grill
Are You In The Dilemma Of Choosing Pellet Grills Vs Gas Grills
We all need to grill the food in life as sometimes dry heat is needed to cook meal and to make it even tastier. But even in the grilling, we are all always caught in the question. Like pellet grills vs gas grills to go with which style of the grilling. Pellet grills vs gas grills all of us at least one time have surely encountered the situation. When the person needs to heat the meal not completely or mildly. And then come to the requirement or the question of the pellet grills vs gas grills. So are you one of them, who is seeking the best choice between the pellet grills vs gas grills.
Then this article is going to be very helpful for you to find from the method of pellet grills vs gas grills, what is best?
So before starting the first question that can hit your mind is what is the grilling in the first place. So, grilling is a method of cooking in which dry heat is given to the surface of the meal. Basically from above, below, or to the side which can be made both by the pellet grills vs gas grills. Grilling uses a lot of direct, radiant heat and is best for fast-cooking meat and vegetables.
What Are The Cons Of Pellet Grills And Charcoal Grills
Ive summarized the pros of both grills, and now, lets talk about the cons of these grill types.
The cons of using pellet grills include:
- These grills run on electricity, so youll need an outlet nearby
- Not everyone likes the wood-smoked taste
- Once the hopper is loaded with hardwood pellets, youll have to burn them completely to be able to change wood flavors
And here are the disadvantages of charcoal grills:
- Most charcoal grills are difficult to clean up
- Theres a steep learning curve until you get the hang of the airflow
- They need constant supervision
Recommended Reading: Pre Assembled Charcoal Grill
Which Grill Is Right For You
Pellet and gas grills are great cookers that can turn out amazing food. To know which is the right choice for you, you need to weigh cost, ease of use, cooking style and any safety concerns.
Go with a pellet grill if price is no object and your goal is to smoke meat low and slow, infusing it with incredible smokey goodness.
Gas grills are a better choice if youd prefer a low-cost, straightforward, potentially portable option, and prize high heat for searing over smoky wood flavor.
Temperature Range And Temperature Control
Pellet grills provide you with slow and low cooking procedures. It will take time to cook food and is not ideal for those who want to cook their food in a quick manner or on an urgent basis. Then we have control over the temperature. The temperature control function in pellet grills is obtained and operated on a complicated algorithm that provides the user with impressively accurate temperature controls.
200 degree Fahrenheit to 350 degrees Fahrenheit is the temperature which is provided by pellet grills in general units. This temperature is not fixed for every pellet grill but is used in most of such grills. Some products come with a temperature range up to 600 degrees Fahrenheit too.
On the other hand, a gas grill can work well and without any problems with high temperatures. Some products can reach up to 700 degrees celsius in temperature range without any complications. But the temperature condition to achieve such high units is that the product should be highly qualitative and efficient. Moreover, the temperature control with this function of grilling in gas grills, specifically for the grills with low temperatures, becomes complex compared to the grills with high temperatures.
Read Also: Char Broil Infrared Grill Brush
Convenience And Ease Of Use
When you grill with charcoal, it can be a pain to start. Once started, it requires your constant attention because you dont want your food to burn or the charcoal to flare up too much. When you use a wood pellet grill, you push a button to start, then set the temperature where you know it will give you the flavor that you want and the tenderness that you desire.
After a short heat-up process, youre ready to grill. These grills are also much easier to clean since the pellets burn neatly and have low ash contents.
Wood pellets have the benefit of allowing you to leave the grill and do other activities like preparing other food that you may be serving at your barbecue. A wood pellet grill burns with consistent heat, so you never have to worry about the grill getting too hot or the wood pellets flaring up, burning your meat or fish and making it tough and unpleasant.
What Is A Gas Grill
The gas grill is one of the most popular outdoor cookers on the market. As its name suggests, it uses propane or natural gas to fuel the unit and cook your food. The gas bottle often sits underneath and the fuel travels up a hose into the manifold, a tube that runs along the base of the cooking area. This directs the gas to the valves, which can be adjusted to decrease or increase the amount of gas in the burner.
Once you ignite the grill, small flames appear in the burners holes, but they dont cook your food directly. Instead, the flames heat the rack where your meat sits, giving your meat its characteristic grill marks.
Gas grills also come with many features. A hood allows you to cook whole chickens and roasts, much like an oven. You can also find models with side burners for heating sauces, and warming racks to prevent your meat from going cold before you serve it.
Also Check: Weber Portable Grill Parts
How Long Does It Take For A Pellet Grill To Heat Up
Where a pellet vs gas grill is comparable is in the length of time they take to heat up. Fortunately, both appliances can preheat pretty quickly, typically between 10 and 15 minutes.
Youll find a great advantage to pellet grills, though, as they are specifically designed to prevent flare-ups when preheating.
Although they give you the ability to cook for longer at lower temperatures, getting it ready is as easy as a gas grill.
Which Pellets Are Best For You
The point to remember in this pellet smoker vs. gas grill comparison is that pellet smoker provides you with a lot of space for creativity. The right type of pellet could change your cooking game forever. If you want a slightly fruity smoke on your pies, then use fruit based pellets. Good candidates include apple, cherry, maple, and guava.
If you want to cook meats like steak and cutlets, then go for alder, maple, and mesquite. For fish and seafood, oak is the best choice. For a heavier and more robust flavor, hickory, oak, and pecan are a great choice. There are numerous other pellets to choose from but dont let the wrong pellet ruin your meal.
Fuel Cost Comparison Of Pellet Grilling Vs Charcoal Gas And Electric Grills
Pellet grilled meats and side dishes have an unmistakably superior flavor to other types of grilled foods. For the backyard BBQ aficionado, there is a long standing debate about the cost of pellet grilling versus other types of grilling. We are here to put that debate to rest!
Using a one hour cook at 225 degrees to compare costs of using a charcoal grill, gas grill, electric grill or pellet grill, you may be surprised at which is the most expensive! As in all things, it also isnt just about the cost you need to consider your time, as well as the resulting flavors of your BBQ session to determine how much bang you get for your buck!
Assuming the use of 38 charcoal briquettes plus starter fuel per cooking session, charcoal grills have fuel costs of a whopping $2.85 per cookout. Charcoal grilling additionally requires quite a bit of time to get your grill to temperature, and to monitor the grill during cooking.
Gas grills using propane cost about $1.20 per hour use, for a 60,000 btu grill running at 70% heat output. This is typical of the average use of a gas grill, as we dont usually use the grill at 100% usage for an hour. Running all burners on medium ends up being about 70%-75% of maximum usage. While gas grills are usually quick to get up to temperature, there is minimal resulting grilled flavor. Many people add water soaked wood during gas grilling to increase BBQ flavor, but that also adds an additional cost to the overall grilling cost.
Happy pellet grilling!
Pellet Vs Gas Grills The Differences In Searing Performance
As Ive discussed above, as a general rule you will find a gas grill will more quickly get up to temperature and achieve a higher grilling/searing temperature. But why is that? Well, quite simply, its due to energy density. The combustion of propane gas is releasing more energy than the size of pellet fire in a typical pellet grill.
But what temperatures do you really need at the grate to achieve good searing/grilling performance? Well, as a general rule you want to achieve at least 450 degrees. Below that temp, you are not going to get the grill marks on your food, you wont hear the meat sizzle and you wont see it properly caramelise. Can all pellet grills actually achieve and exceed that required 450 degrees? Many yes, but not all. Some pellet grills need a little assistance.
Some Z Grill pellet grills will struggle to reach/exceed 450 degrees for reasonable grilling/searing performance without the assistance of some GrillGrates: Image ZGrills.com
Typical examples of pellet grills which are going to struggle to actually grill without some assistance are Gen 1 Traeger Pro Series grills, several Z Grills and basically any pellet grill with a non-PID control panel and without access to direct flames.
Camp Chef pellet grills fitted with PID controllers and Slide N Grill direct flame broiling offer some of the best grilling/searing performance of mid-range pellet grill models: Image Campchef.com
Read Also: Do You Grill Steaks With Lid Open Or Closed
Pellet Grill Vs Gas Grill: How To Choose The Right One For You
There are a few things to consider when buying a gas or pellet grill. Both have their pros and cons, and the right choice for you depends on your needs and preferences. Gas grills are the standard, and theyre easy to use turn on the heat and start cooking.
Pellet grills are more specialized, with many different features that you may or may not need. They were also more expensive. So, whats the best choice for you? Heres a look at the Pellet Grill vs Gas Grill to help you decide.
Wood Pellet Grills Are Less Work
This might be the biggest benefit! Whether youre grilling dinner for your family or preparing a huge spread for a backyard barbecue, the last thing you want to do is have to spend all your time carefully watching over the grill.
While you should certainly supervise the grill when its in use, a wood pellet grill offers more of a set it and forget it option. What do we mean by that? Once youve set the temperature on the control to your target temperature, the grill handles much of the rest.
And theres not a ton of waiting around prior to cooking, either. From the moment you turn on your grill, it may take up to 30 minutes max to reach 350 degrees, and only about 15 minutes more to hit 500 degrees.
Don’t Miss: How To Clean Rust Off Weber Grill
Is A Pellet Grill Good For Grilling
With the right settings, you can get nearly the same results as the best barbecue grill from your pellet grill. However, it is highly unlikely that you can achieve the same without attachments.
Pellet grills are unique because they allow you to smoke and grill your meat in one unit. Unfortunately, because they dont reach high temperatures like gas grills, youre not likely to get the perfect sear for steaks.
If you want to sear meat, youll need to consider finding an attachment that will reach higher temperatures. With that said, if youre not too interested in cooking at high temperatures, pellet grills can be incredibly useful for grilling.
How to Season a Grill: A Step-by-Step Guide