Is Charcoal Grill Better Than Gas

Cut Back On Grilling Red Meat And Processed Meat

Is Charcoal Grill Better than Gas?

Both red and processed meats are associated with a higher risk of cancer. These risks go up when you grill them. Red meats and processed meats are high in fat. This causes them to drip onto coals more, which increases the risk of PAHs. Additionally, you need to grill them for a long time to get them completely cooked. Longer grilling times mean higher temperatures and more smoke, the factors correlated to cancer risk.

Grilling lean meats like chicken, turkey, and fish reduces risk. You can still create HCAs when you grill these meats, but the risk is not as high. You generally dont need to leave these meats on the grill for nearly as long. This reduces the chance HCAs will form.

Additionally, lean meats are shown to be healthier overall, making them a smart choice.

Also Check: What Temp Should I Grill Chicken

Smokey Flavor & Taste

The best reason for cooking with charcoal is its reputation for great taste when grilling thicker meats. Some people love charcoal grills because of the smokey flavor that you can get in the meat you are cooking. For example, a thick piece of meat cooked slowly on a charcoal grill will get a lot of extra flavor from the smoke. This is different from a gas grill, because of the exposed coals. You can also use wood chips, healthy charcoal briquettes or other flavored cooking fuels on charcoal grills, for added and variety of flavor that will rival any steakhouse. As a result, some grill aficionados swear by charcoal grills for better taste on steaks and other thick red meats. If youre mainly looking for this type of great, authentic taste, then a charcoal grill could be your best bet.

A Comparison Of Wood Vs Charcoal Vs Gas Grills

There are several different fuel types you can use when grilling each has its own set of positives and negatives. Wood vs charcoal vs gas are the most common sources of fuel used for grilling, and camping enthusiasts hotly debate which one is superior. Some aspects that affect your fuel choice include flavor, difficulty, and convenience. Read on as we examine the pros and cons of each fuel source and its effect on the cooking process.

Don’t Miss: How To Clean A Stainless Steel Gas Grill

What Is Wrong With Pellet Smokers

One of the most common problems people encounter with pellet grills is abnormal temperature fluctuationsthe controller is set to 250°F, but the grill is dropping to 200°F then climbing to 325°F. Usually people assume that its a mechanical issue and either the controller or RTD probe need to be replaced.

Which One Is Better For You

Which is Better Charcoal or Gas Grills?

This is a debate that has been around for years. Some people swear by charcoal grills while others love gas grills. So, which one is really better? Lets take a look at the pros and cons of both types of grills.

Charcoal grills are cheaper to buy than gas grills. They also give food a nice smoky flavor, which some people prefer over the taste of food cooked on a gas grill. However, charcoal grills can be a hassle to set up and use. They can also be difficult to clean, which means that they require more maintenance than gas grills.

Gas grills are more expensive to buy than charcoal grills, but they are much easier to use. They also heat up faster than charcoal grills, so you can start cooking sooner. However, gas grills do not give food as much of a smoky flavor as charcoal grills.

So, which is the best option for you? If you are looking for a grill that is easy to use and gives food a good flavor, then a gas grill is the best option. But if you are looking for a grill that is cheaper to buy and gives food a smoky flavor, then a charcoal grill is the best option.

Don’t Miss: Best Pellet And Gas Grill Combo

Less Convenience & Control

The major drawback to a charcoal grill is the amount of time and effort that it takes to heat up the grill. It is not uncommon for it to take up to 20 minutes or longer to properly light and heat up your charcoal grill. It can go quicker with a chimney starter. But, if you are not patient, or do not have the time to wait for the charcoal grill to heat up, a charcoal grill might not be for you. This contrasts with a gas grill, which can be lit and heated up within minutes.

In addition, because there is no knob on the grill, you cannot turn the heat up or down. You are at the mercy of the coals. So, if you want multiple zones, you need to be savvy enough to create an area on the grill without charcoal that can be used as a second zone. And, if you want to extend your grilling session, you will need to add more charcoal. If you dont, the temperature will start to decrease.

How Does A Gas Grill Work

On the inside, the gas grill is a bit more complicated than the charcoal grill. The gas grill uses natural gas or propane gas to fuel the fire. The gas grill comes with heat plates to distribute the burners heat, minimizing flare-ups and preventing burner damage. Even though getting it to run is more complicated than the charcoal grill, the gas grill is easier to handle.

Don’t Miss: Best Way To Clean Stainless Steel Grill

Benefits Of Using Charcoal Grills

One of the biggest benefits of using a charcoal grill is that theyre significantly less expensive than gas grills. Most of the time, you can pick up a small charcoal grill for about $20 at the hardware store. Aside from cost, here are a few more benefits to purchasing a charcoal grill:

  • When heated, the coals provide the heat for cooking and generally dont flare up like open flame gas grills. If you want to be safe while grilling, check out these safety tips.
  • Charcoal grills are generally more portable than gas grills.
  • Charcoal burns hotter than gas.
  • Since you cant dial down the heat, you can leave areas without briquettes to control the temperature. This allows you to sear your protein and then allow it to finish cooking in the cooler areas.
  • Many people also prefer the smoke flavor a charcoal grill provides.

Fire Up The Wellness Factor With A Pellet Grill Or Gas Grill

Charcoal Grilling Is BETTER Than Gas Grilling.. Here’s Why!

As you contemplate which type of grill to buy after reading through our pellet grill vs. propane vs. charcoal vs. electric guide, remember that pellet grills do offer a few characteristics that make them a healthier grilling option. First is their ability to maintain human interest. People who buy pellet grills tend to stick with grilling because a pellet grill is so versatile. For example, the same recipe can taste much different depending on which wood pellets you use. After all, hickory wood pellets transmit a flavor that is quite unique from applewood pellets.

Another health benefit of pellet grills relates to their allowing you to grill practically anything in a low, slow way. The freshness and juiciness stay in, making eating lean and nutritious foods a mouth-pleasing experience. No more dull diet meals. Your pellet-cooked ingredients burst with flavor, leaving you satisfied and feeling full.

Finally, pellet grills can be very cost-effective over the long haul, which is healthier for your budget, too! Spend a little more upfront to enjoy a type of cooking you can use season after season. Forget about slogging over the stove you have a pellet smoker and grill to make life enjoyable and tastier!

Purchase a Grilla Grill and become part of the growing pellet smoker grilling or propane gas grilling community today.

Also Check: Grilled Hamburgers On Traeger

You May Like: How Long To Cook Pork Chops On Propane Grill

Gas Vs Charcoal Grill: Tips To Help You Choose

Weighing up the pros and cons of a gas vs charcoal grill can be tough but not with our handy guide

There’s one key decision to make when investing in a new outdoor cooking appliance gas vs charcoal grill? If you’re not sure which is best for you, you’ve come to the right place.

It can be super confusing knowing which kind of grill to choose, especially with so many on the market. And picking between gas and charcoal models doesn’t just impact the fuel you use it also makes a difference to everything else, from how easy your BBQ will be to clean, to the taste of your freshly-grilled food.

To help you choose the best BBQ for your plot, we’ve rounded up the pros and cons of each. And don’t forget that whichever fuel you choose, you’ll need to pick a BBQ that has a big enough grill to feed your family, has the storage and side tables you need, and is also a size that you can store away during the winter.

Benefits Of Gas Grills

Gas grills have many selling features that make them a great choice. They offer more temperature control than charcoal grills, making them ideal if you want to cook many different types of food. Because gas grills use gas to cook, there wont be any additional smoky flavor added to your foods like with charcoal cooking. Unlike charcoal, gas doesnt leave any additional smokey flavor to your foods. Read on for more features of gas grills.

Quick Set-Up: Gas grills take little to no time to set up. Grilling with a gas grill for the first time will require you to hook up your grill to your gas source, like a propane tank. Grilling after the initial setup simply requires that you turn the grill and gas source on.

Easy to Use: Gas grills are easy to use because of their similarity to stoves. Gas grills cook and operate just like gas stoves. If you know how to work a gas stove, you can apply what you know to a gas grill. This includes how to use gas grill accessories like griddles and warming racks. Opt for a gas grill if you like the look and feel of cooking on a stove, but want to be able to grill foods outside as well.

Lights: Gas grills with lights included offer you flexibility and convenience. The lights allow you to see while youre grilling at any time. This is great if you like to grill later in the day or if your outdoor area doesnt get much sunlight.

You May Like: Grilling Temp For Pork Tenderloin

Pellet Grill Vs Gas Grill

Gas grills are extremely popular, especially if you walk into your local big box store. There are all the brand names youâve come to expect, you can get as few or as many square inches of cooking space that youâd like, and the prices can range as high or low as youâre willing to go. Gas grills often time come with some cool features as well, like side burners that run off of the fuel tank.

If youve been a Grilla Grills fan for a while, youll know that we offer a gas grill we call the Primate. It includes many of the above-mentioned features, in addition to offering a superb griddle surface. So its safe to say that we know â and appreciate â gas grills just as much as we do pellet varieties.

While gas grills are the most popular grills on the market there are some very clear positives and negatives in choosing a gas grill.

Benefits Of Gas Grilling

Which is better: A gas or charcoal grill?

To achieve a healthy style of grilling, using gas over charcoal is a really smart decision. Besides the benefits of avoiding the cancer-causing carcinogens, gas grilling is more convenient, ready at any time, and easier to clean up.

To throw a quick BBQ party, you dont have to wait for the charcoal ignites and heat up. When finish grilling, gas grills cool down much faster than their charcoal counterparts and of course, cleanup is a breeze no charcoal or ash to contend with. This also means that a gas grill will be ready to cover and put to bed after a cook much soonerno more waiting in the dark for the grill to cool down!

Charcoal grilling often requires some skills to effectively manage the airflow and cooking temperature. While it may get easier once you get the hang of it, it does require more attention and effort than simply turning a knob. You have to build and bank and tend a fire. You have to pay close attention to where it is hot and where it is not. You have to concentrate and be ready to spend more time standing by the grill.

Gas grills are fueled by liquid propane stored in refillable tanks. Even though charcoal grills are less expensive than gas grills, the cost of charcoal will add up over the years. So in the long run, youll spend less using a gas grill than trying to run a charcoal one.

Don’t Miss: Is A Grill Hotter Open Or Closed

Grilling Over Charcoal Is Objectively Scientifically Better Than Grilling Over Gas

Its a beautiful day. The familys in attendance, side dishes and beer in tow. Your sister-in-law brought a trunk full of Super Soakers. Its BBQ time. Time to kick back in the yard and fire up the stove?

Hmm, that doesnt sound terribly exciting, does it? But thats basically what youre doing when you cook out on a gas grill, which is powered by the same largely flavorless fuel as your kitchen stove.

True fact: Cooking on a gas grill is more convenient than cooking with charcoal.

Its also a lot less special. And, scientifically speaking, it creates less flavorful food.

To understand why, you first need to understand that flavor and taste are not the same thing. Within flavor, we have taste compounds and we have aroma compounds, says Gavin Sacks, a food science researcher at Cornell University. Our brains just arent designed to decouple them.

True fact: A gas grill is more convenient. But it also creates less flavorful food.

In other words, a burger is more than the sum of its ingredients. Sure, there are chemical processes occurring in your food that alter its flavors as it heatsamino acids interacting with sugars, fats breaking down, and so onbut this delicious chemistry happens whether you cook on gas, charcoal, an electric burner, even an engine block.

Case closed.

What About Grilling And My Health

Some barbecue fans arent so worried about their health, figuring they are here for a good time not a long time. But for those who are concerned about being around for a long time as well, there are some factors to consider.

Char is a known carcinogen, and cooking with a charcoal means a lot more char ends up down your gullet.

Its not just the black crunchy bits on the surface of your food that you need to worry about. Meat cooked at high temperatures produces some of the compounds in question.

As we have established, charcoal grills are better at reaching those high temperatures, and controlling the temperature can be more of a struggle.

While controlling the temperature of a gas grill is easier, if you get a good enough gas grill you will still be capable of grilling at temperatures that give a good sear , so grilling with gas is not completely off the hook.

There needs to be more research done on just how many of these compounds need to be ingested before our health is significantly compromised, so it might not be time to panic just yet.

In the meantime, if you cant give up grilling over coal but are concerned, perhaps put a limit on how many times you eat meals cooked over coals per week, or consider grilling with a combination of gas and charcoal.

It may just be a good excuse to buy both a gas and a charcoal grill.

Wrapping it up

Or, perhaps you just need one of each

Read Also: Grilling Pork Temperature

Charcoal Gas Electric Pellet: Here’s What Type Of Grill You Should Buy

From hardwood pellet grills to propane gas burners to charcoal kettles, picking the right backyard cooker isn’t always easy. Here’s your guide to figure out which grill is best for you.

Taylor Martin

CNET Contributor

Taylor Martin has covered technology online for over six years. He has reviewed smartphones for Pocketnow and Android Authority and loves building stuff on his YouTube channel, MOD. He has a dangerous obsession with coffee and is afraid of free time.

Brian Bennett

Senior writer

Brian Bennett is a senior writer for the home and outdoor section at CNET. He reviews a wide range of household and smart-home products. These include everything from cordless and robot vacuum cleaners to fire pits, grills and coffee makers. An NYC native, Brian now resides in bucolic Louisville, Kentucky where he rides longboards downhill in his free time.

Summer has arrived, and that means it’s grill time. Is your backyard cooker ready? Maybe it needs a deep cleaning. If it’s good to go, start prepping for a cookout or low-and-slow barbecue session.

If not, maybe you should consider buying a new grill. The landscape is constantly changing though, and the great debate over which type of grill is better has only grown more complex with more options. It’s no longer just about charcoal vs. gas.

Unless you use a torch or electric starter, charcoal grills take time to light.

Charcoal Gas Or Electric Grill: Which Is Best

Gas vs. charcoal: Which grill is right for you?

The debate over charcoal versus gas can get heated, and adding newer electric grills in to the mix only fuels the fire. The one simple thing you need to know is that choosing the best fuel typecharcoal, gas, or electricfor you is primarily a matter of taste and convenience. Beyond that, a few other factors can help you make the right decision.

You May Like: Macaroni Grill Chain

Popular Articles

More Recipes Like This