How To Make The Best Grilled Cheese With Mayo

How To Make Grilled Cheese

How To Make The Best Grilled Cheese Sandwich | The Best Way

Anyone can make an OK grilled cheese. But we want you to know how to make the BEST grilled cheese sandwich. As ever, its all about technique. Our grilled cheese recipe relies on a few key things:

  • Low heat. You cant rush a great grilled cheese. Low heat allows the bread to toast slowly while the cheese melts.
  • Butter AND mayo. Yes, were saying you need to make your grilled cheese with mayo! This is not the moment to skimp, friends! Any way you slice itwere diagonal people, ourselvesgrilled cheese is an indulgence. Just go ahead and go big! Make it perfect and enjoy.
  • Shredded cheese. Shredded cheese will melt more quickly and evenly than sliced, so its perfect for making a grilled cheese sandwich.
  • White bread. Classic, simple, and a great toaster. Its also really good at soaking up all of that melty butter and creamy mayo.

And The Best Cheese For Grilled Cheese Is

Were partial to regular old cheddar cheesesharp or medium, depending on your preference but a great grilled cheese sandwich can be made out of lots of different cheeses, and our grilled cheese recipe will work with almost any cheese you favor. Here are a few great melters to try:

  • Monterey Jack. This mild, creamy white cheese is an even better melter than cheddar, and is extra lovely mixed with a little sharp cheddar.
  • Gruyère. Nutty and delightfully salty, Gruyère is an Alpine-style cheese that is widely available in the U.S. and makes for a richly flavorful grilled cheese.
  • Raclette. Another gorgeous Alpine-style cheese that is quite literally made for melting. This washed-rind cheese is funkier than Gruyère and will definitely take your grilled cheese into grown-up territory.
  • Blue / Chevré. Tangy chevré or sharp blue cheeses can be delicious additions to a grilled cheese, but we like to use them sparingly and coupled with mild, melty cheeses like Jack or cheddar.

Everything You Need To Know About Making The Best Grilled Cheese Sandwich Mayo Or Butter Lid On Or Off There’s More To A Good Grilled Cheese Recipe Than You Might Think

A grilled cheese sandwich is the first thing a lot of people learn to cook. It was the first thing I learned to cook. Id shave off a few slices from the ubiquitous big orange block of Velveeta in our fridge, slather Roman Meal bread with Promise margarine, and make the best meal nine-year-old me could ever want.

Maybe you didnt grow up grilling processed cheese on squishy sandwich bread. Or maybe you know plenty well how to make grilled cheese, but you want to up your game. Great newsthis grilled cheese party is open to all experience levels!

Recommended Reading: How To Get Grease Off Of Driveway

Variations For The Best Grilled Cheese

Grilled cheese is one of the best foods ever. It is the most ultimate comfort foods ever. Its cheesy, its buttery, its so luscious. One of the most wonderful things about these is the fact that they are so easy to customize. You can mix and match the breads and fillings to your hearts content.

  • Bread: I love sourdough, but any bread you love will work, rye, ciabatta, whole wheat, white, or whatever you desire most. Remember if you use a light weight bread be sure to secure the sandwich with a toothpick.
  • Cheese: A good melty cheese works best but any cheese that you love will work. Use a good strong flavored cheese. Try Colby, provolone, swiss, pepper jack, or Monterey jack. Any cheese will work.
  • Add Ins: Add fillings to make the sandwich even better. Try tomatoes, caramelized onions, mushrooms, cucumbers, avocados, sliced sandwich meat, pepperoni, even thinly sliced apples.

What Can I Add To Grilled Cheese To Make It Better

How To Make the Best Tomato Grilled Cheese Sandwich

To add a ton of flavor to a simple grilled cheese, adding ingredients like chutney, pepper jelly, tomato jam, or bacon jam can totally change the flavor profile. Any jam, any chutney, even dijon mustard, almost any condiment will lend itself to a grilled cheese sandwich, Werlin said.

Don’t Miss: What Is The Biggest Traeger Grill

What Is Good In A Grilled Cheese

You can make avocados and tomato slices, caramelized onions, spinach, arugula, mushrooms, zucchini, and peppers taste delicious. Alternatively, slice of peach, pear, pears, and pineapple, or kiwi can be paired with a grilled cheese. You can often find dried cranberries, raisins, and currants here and there.

The Best Tip For A Perfect Grilled Cheese

My friends, this is a must. I make grilled cheese without butter! Swap out the butter on the outside of the sandwich for mayonnaise. Cook mayonnaise side down in the pan.

Your grilled cheese will come out perfectly golden with a crust that doesnt get soggy and is not greasy!

If the pan is too hot, the cheese wont melt before the outside is cooked. If you notice the cheese taking awhile, cover it with a lid. The steam will help melt the cheese so it cooks evenly!

You May Like: Pork Grill Temperature

What Can I Add To A Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Favorite sliced bread , such as levain, pullmans, sourdough, or walnut. Favorite sliced or grated firm cheeses , such as Cheddar, Gruyere, or Havarti. Favorite soft cheese , such as goat cheese, Brie, or feta. Sandwich-friendly vegetables , such as roasted red peppers, leafy greens, or sliced tomatoes.

Gourmet Grilled Cheese Sandwich

How to Make The Best Grilled Cheese Sandwich (Gourmet Grilled Cheese Recipe)

Have you ever wondered how to up grilled cheese? This gourmet grilled cheese sandwich is the grown-up version of the good ol sandwich we all love so much. Expect a dreamy combination of cheddar, brie, and apple slices. The center is ooey-gooey and creamy, and every bite is delicious. Bread choice? Sourdough sandwich bread, of course!

Recommended Reading: Old Weber Grill Parts

Recommended Reading: What Temp Do You Grill Pork Tenderloin

Should You Use Mayo Or Butter For Grilled Cheese

Smoked mayonnaises smoke point makes it perfect for making grilled cheese sandwiches because they have a higher point of flavor than butter. Alternatively, you can cook the sandwich during a slightly higher heat to crisp up and fluffier it up. Furthermore, mayo can be spread very easily over breads.

What To Serve With Grilled Cheese

Everyone knows its a tradition for a grilled cheese sandwich to be paired with creamy tomato soup, of course! Its a perfect combination of crunchy and creamy, great for a busy weekday or rainy day!

Another great complement to a tomato grilled cheese sandwich is a crispy tossed salad topped with a bright and tangy vinaigrette and some croutons!

Don’t Miss: What Model Is My Weber Grill

Why Use Mayo With The Butter

Crazy as it may sound, but mayonnaise mixed with butter spread on your bread is absolutely divine. If you have never tried it, its a MUST. And this is the perfect recipe to try it on. So why should you use mayo on your grilled cheese?

  • Store bought mayo has a higher smoke point than butter. This means that it takes longer for the bread to get that golden crispy outside. And since it takes longer, the cheese has more time to melt and get all ooey-gooey. So it creates a perfect golden crunchy exterior and fluffy melty interior.
  • Mayo is obviously easier to spread. Butter from the fridge can be hard and while trying to spread it on the bread it can tear the bread. That just ruins the whole sandwich. So mixing the butter and mayo creates a perfect spreadable topping.
  • Butter gives it the best flavor. Thats why we use a combination. The butter creates the flavor and the mayo creates a golden crust that spreads evenly.

Field Roast Smoked Original Chao Slices

How to Make the Best Grilled Cheese Using Mayo

For the best vegan grilled cheese, I recommend the Field Roast Chao Cheese Smoked slices, said Brandi Doming, author of The Vegan 8 cookbook. They taste authentic like dairy cheese, melt, and are incredibly delicious.

She also praised the plant-based cheeses rich flavor, which brings a smokiness to the sandwich.

My daughter loves them, as well, Doming added. There is no off texture or taste, just delicious cheesy goodness!

Gunjan Dudani, founder of Kiipfit, endorsed the mozzarella cheese-style shreds from So Delicious Dairy Free.

I love its rich texture when cooked, she said. It has nice soft and soothing taste that is very close to the regular cheese. It melts well and stretches just as expected.

Made with coconut oil and potato starch, this dairy-free cheese is Dudanis favorite for grilled cheese sandwiches, but she also likes to eat it straight from the bag.

Don’t Miss: Convert Natural Gas Grill To Propane Weber

How To Make The Best Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Grilled cheese sandwiches are simple and easy to make. They require few ingredients, yet provide an abundance of comfort. This is part of their allure. However, to make the best grilled cheese sandwich, the ingredients you choose to work with? Well, they matter. So lets start with what matters most the cheese.

The Secret Ingredient For A Best

We can all agree that everyone loves new ways to improve on old favorites. Do you know how to make a perfectly round egg for a breakfast sandwich? Or how to make pie in a Mason jar lid? Now you do!

One of the latest and greatest kitchen hacks involves upgrading your grilled cheese with one simple secret ingredient: mayonnaise.

Recommended Reading: What Temp To Grill Pork Chops On Gas Grill

What Can I Add To Grilled Cheese

  • Sun-dried tomatoes are caramelized and cheddar cheese is melted into the caramelized onion.
  • A delicious array of tomato, basil, and mozzarella!
  • The grilled figs and walnuts are topped with goat cheese.
  • It is composed of olive tapenade and Gruyere.
  • Various flavours from Turkey, Havarti and sliced.
  • Adding grilled vegetables, fontina, and butter on a warm fall day.
  • Sliced almonds, apples, ham, and Swiss cheeses.
  • A spicy mushroom salad, spinach salad, and crisp Gruyre with an arugula garnish.
  • Best Types Of Cheese For Grilled Cheese

    Mayo Grilled Cheese on Sourdough

    Once youve masted the classic grilled cheese sandwich, you may want to up your game. In fact, I highly recommend it! You can add things like cooked bacon slices and of course, different kinds of cheese.

    Ideas for melty cheese include provolone, mozzarella, American, and of course, I already mentioned cheddar and colby jack.

    Sometimes all you need to do is make some simple changes to a classic. So give using mayo for grilled cheese a try, then circle on back and tell me what you think.

    The next time youre stressing out about whats for dinner, keep the good ole grilled cheese sandwich in mind. Delicious doesnt need to mean fancy!

    If youre a grilled cheese lover, share this with your friends and family theyll thank you for making them the best grilled cheese recipe ever!

    Oh, and dont forget to serve some soup alongside whats your favorite match?

    Recommended Reading: How To Clean A Stainless Steel Bbq Grill

    Is Mayonnaise Good On Grilled Cheese

    Theres no feeling like a sandwich without mayo for making grilled cheese better. Despite this, the taste is not satisfactory. When it comes to butter, we still prefer traditional, but you may prefer to pick up the mayo if it is not already softened on your counter. It should result in a pretty good result for you.

    Follow Your Heart Smoked Gouda Slices

    As someone who first started eating vegan cheese 30 years ago, I can say both variety and quality have improved drastically, said Anya Todd, a dietitian specializing in vegan nutrition. That said, Follow Your Heart has been around since 1970, and their vegan cheese slices are still one of my faves. They melt and stretch, which is exactly what I want in a grilled cheese sammich!

    Vora also endorsed Follow Your Heart, specifically the smoked gouda flavor.

    For a more nontraditional grilled cheese, the Follow Your Heart Smoked Gouda Slices are a great option, she said. It has more of a smoky flavor but still melts really well.

    Don’t Miss: Grease Off Concrete

    Tips And Tricks For The Best Grilled Cheese Sandwich

  • Heat: Always keep the heat to medium-low if you want to make an ideal grilled cheese sandwich that has a melty cheese and golden crispy crust. Medium-low heat prevents the bread from scorching too fast and helps in melting cheese.

  • Butter + mayo: Try the combination of butter and mayonnaise if you want that perfectly crispy exterior and buttery brilliance.

  • No matter which type of bread you are using, make sure to use the thick-sliced bread. Using thick sliced bread stops it from being soggy.

  • You can always make it with 1 cheese slice, but the more cheese the better. I have used 3 cheese slices, you can use up to 4 cheese slices.

  • If you dont want to use sliced cheese, then you can surely use shredded cheese here, it works perfectly fine. Shredded cheese melts more quickly than sliced ones.

  • Slicing: You can slice the sandwiches any way you like, but I found that the grilled cheese sandwiches that are cut diagonally taste much better.

  • You can use any skillet/pan you like for toasting this sandwich, but I personally prefer using a well-seasoned cast iron pan for toasting. No matter what pan you are using, make sure to wipe it clean before making the next sandwich.

  • Cover with the lid: When making a grilled cheese sandwich, cover the pan with a lid, and cook until the cheese is melted in the center. The steam helps melt the cheese. Flip it once, and when it is crispy from the underside remove the lid to crisp up the bread.

  • Making Incredible Grilled Cheese

    Maple Grilled Cheese from How to Make the Perfect Grilled ...

    This takes the same amount of time as your regular grilled cheese but will taste 5 times better.

  • Assemble: Lay two slices of cheese between two pieces of bread.
  • Combine: In a small bowl combine the mayo and butter.
  • Spread: Spread the butter mixture on the outside of the bread.
  • Fry: Place in the basket of an air fryer and 360 degrees and fry for 5 min. Flip and fry for another 5 minutes.
  • Recommended Reading: Pork Chop Grilling Times

    Read Also: Clean Grill Pan

    Making More Than One Grilled Cheese At A Time

    For me, its easier to use a 10-inch skillet and grill just one or two sandwiches at once. Unless you have an amazing stovetop with giant burners, its difficult to have even heat distribution across a very large skillet, leaving your sandwiches with pale patches.

    Need to make a bunch of grilled cheese sandwiches all at once? Try it in the oven:

  • Put bread slices butter/mayo-side-down on a sheet pan, place cheese over each bread slice, and bake in a preheated 425°F oven until the cheese is bubbly.
  • Then close the sandwiches and bake until toasty, about 5 minutes longer.
  • The sandwiches wont be quite the same, being baked rather than grilled, but theyll all be ready to serve at once.

    Recommended Reading: How To Clean Stainless Steel Bbq

    The Best Pan For Grilled Cheese

    The pan is just as important, if not more so, than the bread and cheese. A flimsy skillet will grill your sandwich unevenly. A skillet thats too small makes it hard to maneuver the sandwich.

    For one sandwich at a time, I like a 10-inch cast-iron skillet.

    Grilled cheese sandwiches dont really stick to the pan, so if you dont have a nonstick pan, its fine. I prefer a cast-iron pan.

    You May Like: How To Clean Infrared Grill

    Read Also: Convert Weber Natural Gas Grill To Propane

    The Best Grilled Cheese Sandwich Recipe

    Well, as the mom of teenagers I can tell you, thats a hard no. Ive taught our kids how to make a good grilled cheese, but its a fact that they dont come out of the womb with the inherant ability to make a mean grilled cheese.

    In fact, even my grilled cheese skills were lacking, right up to several years ago. I just didnt know it.

    Because to be honest, I think Ive always made a pretty darn good sandwich.

    But when it comes to my husbands family, they take their approach to grilled cheese very seriously.

    My husband talks about making 35-mile family road trips to get the best grilled cheese from a country diner in his childhood. Clearly this family has high expectations.

    So you know I had to up my sandwich game when I married into a family with a history like this.

    Heres my secret.You make the best grilled cheese using mayo.

    For real. I grew up with buttered bread but I have since upped my game by making grilled cheese with mayo.

    No pressure or anything

    From little kids to grown ups like, me, a grilled cheese sandwich is one of those classic recipes everyone can enjoy. A few humble ingredients are transformed into a creamy-crispy-gooey sandwich loved by all!

    But a grilled cheese made with mayo? Prepare to be amazed

    The Best Vegan Cheeses For Grilled Cheese Sandwiches

    The Best Grilled Cheese Sandwich Recipe

    A grilled cheese sandwich is an easy-to-make American classic. While this dish might not seem compatible with a vegan diet, the truth is there are many ways to give the bread and melty cheese combo a dairy-free twist.

    Vegan cheese has come so far in the last 5-10 years from barely edible to actually quite delicious, said Nisha Vora, creator of the vegan cooking blog Rainbow Plant Life. However, not all vegan cheeses are suitable for a grilled cheese sandwich, so you need to be selective.

    She believes the most important factor to consider when choosing a dairy-free cheese for a grilled cheese sandwich is meltability.

    A lot of vegan cheeses just dont melt well enough to use for a grilled cheese, she explained. In terms of taste, I prefer a mild-flavored cheese because its similar to the classic grilled cheese I ate as a kid.

    Below, Vora and other vegan culinary experts share their favorite dairy-free cheeses for a grilled cheese sandwich.

    Recommended Reading: Pit

    Popular Articles

    More Recipes Like This