Which Is Better Charcoal Or Gas Grill

Charcoal Vs Gas Grill: Which Is Best For You

Gas Grill vs Charcoal Grill – Which is Better?

Grill season is in full swing. If youre hoping to entertain in your backyard and host the biggest barbecues on the block, you need to make sure your grill is fired up and ready to go. But this obviously prompts the age-old question: should you go gas or charcoal for your grilling needs?

Grill masters the world over have wrestled with this question, and everyone seems to have their own answer based on their family recipes, the foods they tend to grill the most, their most valued experts advice, and good old-fashioned intuition. Today, we will talk you through the pros and cons of charcoal and gas grills, so you can decide which is best for you.

Get everything you need for your next cookout at Grayco Hardware & Home Center. Find my Grayco.

Summer Grilling: Charcoal Vs Gas Barbeques

Ever since the dawn of the modern day Barbecues the debate has raged which is better, gas or charcoal grills? Today were going to be examining the difference between the two and informing you of which option is best for your needs. So the next time youre gathered around a friends backyard in Melbourne, youll be able to weigh in on this debate.

Today were going to be examining the difference between the two and informing you of which option is best for your needs. So the next time youre gathered around a friends backyard in Melbourne, youll be able to weigh in on this debate.

Benefits Of Using A Charcoal Grill

Here is why people love charcoal grill:

  • When you are grilling the meat at low temperature, the smoke, aroma, and flavor enters the food and make it super tasty.
  • The charcoal grills come with wheels and allow them to lift easily. The portability helps to make your camping tour enjoyable with grilled food.
  • The charcoal grill comes with a simple mechanism that makes it easy to maintain.
  • This grill is affordable and long-lasting. You can use the grill for long years.

Notes: If you are convinced with the benefits of a charcoal grill and want to have one, then check this article about the best charcoal grill under 200 dollars.

Also Check: Grilling Pork Temp

Buying Gas For Your Barbecue

Make sure you check the instructions on your gas barbecue before buying fuel for it. It will need one of:

  • Propane
  • Butane

Most gas barbecues use propane, and will come with the right regulator attached, which is the valve you connect up to your grill. The valve will usually need screwing on, but green canisters have clip-on valves, which are easier to attach.

The more burners you use, the more gas you will use, but as a general guide a 13kg canister of propane will fuel a three-burner grill for around 15 hours.

You can buy gas canisters and refills at some DIY stores, garden centres, petrol stations and specialist retailers. A small deposit of around £30 is usually required to rent a canister, and the fuel itself will cost roughly the same.

Returning the canister once youre finished will get your deposit refunded, and if you bought it they can be recycled free of charge too.

Ready to buy a gas barbecue? Go straight to our Best Buy barbecues to see the best grills you can buy.

Drawbacks To Using Charcoal Grills


Despite all these wonderful things, the one major setback for most people is waiting for the coals to heat up. Even if you have one of those fancy chimney starters, it can still take 1520 minutes for the coals to reach the proper temperature. Here are a few more negative aspects:

  • Charcoal is messy and requires much more clean up afterward.
  • Ashes can get in your food.
  • Youll have to add more charcoal for longer cooking sessions.
  • These grills dont come with many additional features.
  • Depending if you use self-ignite charcoal or charcoal fluid to start a fire, it can give off an unpleasant petrochemical smell. This smell can seep into the taste of your food.

I own both a gas and charcoal grill however, more often than not, I end up using my gas grill out of ease and convenience. Ill break out the charcoal grill if I happen to have some extra time on my hands.

While I certainly cant settle the debate about whether a gas grill is superior to a charcoal grill, you do have a few things to think about before you go out and buy either. Make sure you select the best option for you and your family.

Also Check: Boneless Chicken Breast Gas Grill

Cons Of Charcoal Grills

Despite having all these astounding things, charcoal grills also suffer from some drawbacks. The key setbacks are as follow:

  • Charcoal grills take too much time to startup. It needs at least 15-20 minutes to reach the proper temperature for grilling.
  • Charcoal is messy and demands more afterward cleanup.
  • There is a chance of getting the ashes into your food.
  • It does not feature any additional options
  • If you use self-ignite charcoal or charcoal fluid to set the fire, it may give off an unpleasant smell.

What Food Is Charcoal Best For

Charcoal shines if you do a lot of searing, and prefer that deep, smoky flavor.

Youve probably heard that charcoal just tastes better. But how much truth is behind that?

Good Housekeeping magazine did a blind taste test in 1998. They found that taste testers could not tell the difference between burger patties cooked on gas and charcoal

But when it came to thicker cuts of meat such as steaks which required longer cooking times, the difference in taste became apparent.

If you are prepared to invest a little more time into your cooking, do a lot of searing or even think you might want to try using your grill as a smoker, then charcoal is right for you.

Don’t Miss: Clean Stainless Steel Grill

Charcoal Vs Gas Grill: Cost Safety And Taste Explained

Not sure which type to choose? With so many different kinds of grills out there I cant really blame you.

Both charcoal and gas grills are awesome in their own respective ways.

To learn more about charcoal vs gas grill differences, just read more.

Ive made this thorough guide to not only explain the pros and cons of these two grill types but also make your decision about purchasing the right type of grill for you much easier.

Some of us grillers love starting a fire from scratch and cooking slowly for hours while others just want their burger done fast and without any mess.

Youll soon find out which type of griller are you and what type of grill suits you the most.

Cooking is a great bonding activity for every person. Grilling, on the other hand, is the best way of cooking as this technique cooks the food in a much more flavorful way.

Its also a great excuse to get out of the house.

Your grilling depends on the type of grill you use.

Grills vary from pellet, electric, and even wood-burning grills. Did you know that among all grill kinds, charcoal and gas grills are the most widely used? They are also more valuable and efficient than other types of grills.

Flavor and convenience usually go hand in hand.

If you aim at the most convenient grill then the flavor should be the least of your concern. For instance, if you choose an electric grill, then it wont guarantee the best grilling experience.

Why Use Charcoal Grills

Gas vs. charcoal: Which grill is right for you?

A charcoal grill is perfect for tasteful and smokey-flavored food.

Lets take a look at these benefits:

Small Cost

Charcoal grills are way cheaper compared to gas grills.

They are a great choice for low and medium-income earners since they serve the same purpose as the gas grill.

Higher Temperature

These grills provide high heat which is ideal for roasting and searing.

Produces A Unique Flavor

Charcoal is rich in lignin and cellulose components. These components provide a dark color and a smoky flavor.

Just like gas grills, charcoal grills have their own certain limitations. These include:

Heat Control

It is difficult to control the heat.

If you dont watch your food, it can be burnt easily.

Health Risks

Charcoal is dirty to handle. Lighting up also takes some time. This may produce flare-ups which when bonded with the food are risky for your health.

Also if the charcoal in the grill burns out, you need to add more and by doing so if the charcoal doesnt get enough oxygen may deposit soot on your food.

Also Check: Temperature Control Akorn Grill

Does Charcoal Taste Better Than Gas

Charcoal tastes better because you use briquettes or wood as fuel. At gas grilling, you use gas as a fuel.

Charcoal is natural fuel for cooking so it gives more flavor to the food while gas doesnt.

Charcoal or wood from different fruits gives that special flavor that people like to use to increase the dish flavor.

Which Is Better: A Gas Grill Or A Charcoal Grill

The debate over which type of grill is better, a gas grill or a charcoal grill, depends largely on what type of cooking one wants to achieve. Both types of grill have pros and cons that will affect the way foods get cooked, thereby making each one valuable and detrimental for certain cooks. But as a general assessment, if heat control is important to the cook, the gas grill is preferable. For a more even heating surface, however, the charcoal grill is the way to go.

With either a gas grill or a charcoal grill, the cook will find immensely different pros and cons. Critics of charcoal grills cite difficulty in controlling heat fluctuations and a lack of control in heat levels, whereas a gas grill allows for easy adjustment of flame intensity. This becomes helpful when cooking different types of food at the same time meat on one side of the grill and vegetables on the other, for example, or red meat on one side and fish on the other. A charcoal grill is the same temperature throughout the entire grill, making it more difficult to avoid burning certain foods unless the cook pays very close attention.

You May Like: What Temperature Do You Grill Shrimp

Is It Healthier To Grill With Gas Or Charcoal

In most studies, gas grills can be healthier for you and the environment than charcoal grills. Natural gas or propane burn very cleanly, so there isn’t much toxic chemicals adhering to your food. When using a charcoal grill, two types of chemicals called PAHs can get on your food. PAHs are believed to be carcinogenic. Charcoal also produces copious amounts of carbon monoxide and can put soot into the air. The production of charcoal is considered to be more harmful to the environment than the process of producing natural gas or propane.

One thing to remember is that some of the most potentially harmful chemicals come from animal fats and meat drippings burning in a hot flame rather than the emissions from a particular type of fuel. You can still get nasty PAHs on your gas grill when the food drips on the burners.

Are There Other Types Of Grills Than Charcoal Or Gas Grills

Charcoal vs Gas Grill â Which is Better? We Know Which We ...

For the majority of this post, we focused on mainstream gas or charcoal grill styles to give you a good overview if a charcoal or gas grill would be best for you. However, there are other types of grills that dont neatly fit into the standard descriptions. Here are brief overviews of 4 types of specialized gas or charcoal grills that you can buy.

Recommended Reading: Best Way To Clean Stainless Steel Bbq

Is There A Taste Difference

Searing. Searing is the process of browning the surfaces of meats, especially steaks. When done properly there are chemical reactions, the Maillard reaction and caramelization chief among them, that create rich, complex, sweet and savory compounds on the surface. Searing also dries the surface making a satisfyingly crunchy crust. Despite what you have been told, searing does not seal in juices. And when it comes to steak, you want an even sear from edge to edge, no grill marks.

Most charcoal grills can usually easily outsear gas grills because they simply produce more direct infrared heat. A few gas grills, usually expensive ones, come with special sear burners that can do a good job of searing.

The most convincing argument for gas? Probably 90% of the worlds greatest and most expensive steakhouses grill their rare aged prime beef with gas. This is not just a matter of convenience or price. With the prices that steakhouses charge, they can afford any fuel they want. Why do so many use gas?

But heres another fact worth noting: Nowadays barbecue restaurants are springing up like mushrooms after a rainstorm and many of them are making incredibly good low and slow ribs, pulled pork, and beef brisket. The vast majority of them are using large smokers that use natural gas to produce their heat, and they burn logs for smoke.

Charcoal Vs Gas Grilling: Which Is Healthier

There are few things more satisfying than cooking over a grill with an open flame. We get to enjoy being outside, take in the unique smoky flavors that only grilling provides, and most likely hang out with our friends. However, when it comes to grilling, you have two choices: gas or charcoal. You might be wondering which is the healthier option? Unfortunately for the charcoal fans out there, gas appears to be the hands-down healthier option. Don’t give up hope, though, there are a few ways to make charcoal grilling healthier.

Its good to get a complete picture if you havent already chosen between gas and charcoal. Here are a few pros and cons to help you choose.

Read Also: Best Temp To Grill Pork Tenderloin

Charcoal Vs Gas Grill And Beyond: Your Guide To Different Types Of Grills

Hard wood pellet grills, propane gas burners, to charcoal kettles, picking the right backyard cooker for your needs isn’t easy. We break it all down so shopping for one is easy.

Summer has arrived, and that means it’s grill time. Is your backyard cooker ready? Maybe it needs a deep cleaning. If it’s good to go, start prepping for a cookout or low and slow barbecue session.

If not, maybe you should consider buying a new grill. The landscape is constantly changing though, and the great debate over which type of grill is better has only grown more complex with more options. It’s no longer just about charcoal vs. gas.

Get the CNET How To newsletter

If you have little grill knowledge or are in the market to replace your worn out one with a shiny new barbecue grill, here are the five main types of grills you can choose from.

Unless you use a torch or electric starter, charcoal grills take time to light.

A classic and favorite among purists, the charcoal grill is often heralded as a superior or more authentic way to grill food. Though they come in all shapes and sizes, they all use charcoal briquettes or lump charcoal as a fuel source, which produces a distinct, strong and smoky flavor.

Charcoal grills are usually pretty affordable, starting as little as $30 and going up to $300. They also come in a bevy of different styles:

What Are The Main Differences Between Charcoal And Gas Grills

Gas vs Charcoal Grill | Which Should You Buy?

The most obvious difference between a charcoal or gas grill is the fuel source. Both types of grill provide heat to cook food in a contained area, but charcoal grills burn charcoal to create heat while a gas grill uses gas like propane. This is really the biggest difference and almost all of the other differences come from this one fact!

To cook on the charcoal grill, you start charcoal on fire, then control heat by creating more or less air flow in the cooking area. This is controlled by adjusting dampers on the top and bottom of the grill. More oxygen through more air flow means the flames will reach a higher temperature, while less oxygen means youll be cooking at a lower temperature.

On a gas grill, you turn knobs to allow more or less gas to flow through the cooking burners. By using either a built in electric starter, or some other flame source the gas is ignited. You can then turn the knobs to dial in your heat to precisely where you would like it to be.

Heres a rundown comparing other factors that are different between charcoal and gas grills.

Recommended Reading: How To Keep Mice Out Of Your Grill

Charcoal And Gas Grills Go Head To Head

Gas and charcoal grills are both excellent options for new grillmasters. Theyre easy to find, relatively inexpensive to buy, their fuel is cheaper than most other options, and they excel at cooking with higher temperatures. Despite their similarities, they have some critical differences in their cooking methods to consider when grilling poolside or on your patio.

Charcoal Vs Gas Grills: Which Is Better

If you are expecting us to say “this one is better than the other,” you’ll be disappointed. There are times when we prefer a gas grill over charcoal and vice versa. There are certain benefits to using gas and disadvantages as well. When deciding which one is better, it can be helpful to know the things each type does well to decide whether you want to cook on gas or charcoal grills.

Don’t Miss: Weber Model Number Location

Popular Articles

More Recipes Like This