How To Make Grilled Cheese In An Air Fryer

Using Butter Or Mayo To Make Grilled Cheese

How to Make Air-Fried Grilled Cheese | Air Fryer Recipes | Well Done

You can use softened butter to coat your bread in this recipe or an easier option of lightly coating the outside bread with mayo. When I share this with folks I usually get one of two reactions. They have either grown up with the idea of using mayo on the outside of their grilled cheese or they are completely against even trying it.

Truth be told, in this recipe, made in the air fryer, I really cant taste a difference. I do find the mayo as an easier way to butter my bread, but you do you.

How To Make Air Fryer Grilled American Cheese Sandwich

  • Butter one side of each piece of bread.
  • Place American Cheese in between both slices with the butter side out.
  • Mayonnaise is also great to use for this Air Fryer Grilled American Cheese Sandwich.
  • The sandwich then cooks in the Air Fryer or the Crisplid. .

If you like tomatoes, a nice slice of a tomato inside the sandwich is fantastic too!

We keep our bread frozen, so it is easier to butter.

Please check my article on How to Properly Season Air Fryer Basket before starting.

What To Serve With Grilled Cheese

If you want fries with your grilled cheese you can cook them at the same time with the grilled cheese in your air fryer basket. My favorite brand of frozen fries are Alexa or Ore Ida. I will cook frozen french fries at 350 for 12 minutes.;

Chips and pickles

My recipe 5 Ingredient Tomato Blender Soup would also be good with grilled cheese.

Read Also: How To Cook Steak On Indoor Grill

Key Ingredients For Air Fryer Grilled Cheese

Mayonnaise Hear me out. A little mayo on the outside of the sandwich is the magic that gives you a perfectly-grilled grilled cheese. A lot of people opt for butter on the bread or in the skillet BUT! Mayo has a higher smoke point than butter, which means your sandwich will withstand the heat better. Youll get a nicer texture from the bread on the outside and a much gooier melt from the cheese on the inside.Bread So we kept things very simple in this recipe and used a classic white bread, though we did go with an organic brand. Just personal preference! You can use any bread you like. Honey wheat adds just the slightest sweetness that I really enjoy from time to time.Cheese Again, we opted for the classic-grilled-cheese cheese here American. And again we used an organic version. Like with the bread, though, you can use any cheese you like. A gooey, melty pepper jack grilled cheese sandwich from the air fryer is so good if you like a little heat. Dont hesitate to combine a few different cheeses, either.

We Love Airfryer Grilled Cheese

Make a Perfect Grilled Cheese Using the Air Fryer

I’ve talked about my airfryer several times on my site. It was a Christmas gift from my mom back in 2016. I have had it a full year now and I am still finding new uses for it. Most recently, I discovered it makes a perfect grilled cheese.

If you want to learn more about air fryers be sure to visit our air fryer category page, there you will learn how to clean your air fryer;and the most;common air fryer mistakes! If you are ready to buy an air fryer, you can read;air fryer reviews and learn about the;best air fryers on the market!

That’s right! Air Fryer Grilled Cheese for the WIN! Yes, we made this sandwich in a greaseless fryer! Just thinking about pairing that air fryer grilled cheese with some tomato soup has got my belly rumbling. Does the grilled cheese and tomato soup combo, bring you back to your childhood? It does for me! Now, I am just updated that combo to make it an air fryer grilled cheese and tomato soup!

So it is said that the grilled cheese was born around the 1920s. It was an inexpensive meal that could be made with bread and American cheese. Those two ingredients were readily available and cheap! This type of sandwich is now popular among many cultures!

Also Check: Can All Propane Grills Be Converted To Natural Gas

What Kind Of Cheese Is Best For A Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Use any kind of cheese you like, as long as its cheese that melts well. Sharp cheddar cheese is a favorite because its so flavorful but there are so many kinds of cheese that work: Havarti, Swiss, munster, provolone, pepper Jack, Monterey Jack, soft cheeses like goat cheese or blue cheese, vegan cheese, the list is endless. Choose any type of cheese that melts well. If you really love American cheese slices, go for it. Its a classic combination!;

Slice the cheese from a block or use pre-sliced cheese. Shredded cheese works, too, its just a little messier.

Which Air Fryer Do I Use

After doing extensive air fryer research, I decided on this GoWise 5.8 quart Air Fryer.

I should also say that this isn’t sponsored but if you order from Amazon using any of these links or images, I get a small kickback!

I went with the 5.8 quart because it’s the perfect size for me and my family. It is large enough to cook two sandwiches in, a whole chicken, or a big batch of fries without things getting too crowded.

Anything smaller would have been kind of pointless to me. It also has more temperature controls and more cooking options than a lot of the other air fryers on the market do. I also loved that it came with a whole entire cookbook and temperature manual for various foods.

Don’t Miss: Why Are Evo Grills So Expensive

How To Make Grilled Cheese In The Air Fryer:

The first thing to do is butter one side of two pieces of bread.

Put two pieces of cheese between the bread with the buttered side facing out.

You can use any type of cheese you like. We usually keep it simple with the Kraft singlesits what we grew up with!

If you want an EXTRA CHEESY sandwich, sprinkle a little shredded cheddar between the sliced cheese. Its amazing.

Cook each side in the air fryer for four minutes. It doesnt get much easier than this!

Is Mayo Or Butter Better For Grilled Cheese

How To Make a Grilled Cheese Sandwich in an Air Fryer

I would say this is a cultural thing as I have never used mayo in place of butter to make a grilled cheese. Butter is the more popular choice when it comes to this classic sandwich. However, some may prefer mayo and you wont know which you like better until you try both. So, I would give mayo a try in place of the butter just to try it. It will be up to your taste preferences on which one is better.;

Recommended Reading: Which Weber Spirit Grill Do I Have

Best Cheese For Grilled Cheese

The classic sandwich uses white bread with American cheese. However, any melty cheese is good in a grilled cheese in my opinion!

Ive used Cheddar, Swiss, Monterey Jack, Pepper Jack, Provolone, Gouda and probably a dozen other cheese varieties. They all have made for a great sandwich!

Use any kind of melty cheese you like and youre golden.

Easy Air Fried Grilled Cheese

Gosh, these are so good and amazing. Air fryer grilled cheese sandwiches are life changing! . We knew it would work, but didnt realize how the air fryer makes perfect grilled cheese! If you dont want to use a lot fo butter, you dont have to. Even with little butter or a light spray of olive oil, the bread toasts perfectly in the air fryer. Whether its for a quick snack for the kids or a seriously delicious lunch, these are fantastic. The bread toasts perfectly and the cheese melts fantastic.

Recommended Reading: How Long To Grill Chicken

Key To Success #1 Light On The Butter

The key to a toasty grilled cheese is to go light on the butter.

If you slather on the butter, your sandwich will be a soggy mess.

So just put a thin layer of butter on each side of the sandwich.

For my Grilled Cheese Sandwiches, I like to use a light butter spread like Country Crock.

It is much easier to spread the butter evenly without tearing the bread.

You can also use softened real butter if you prefer.

Just use the defrost setting on your microwave for a few seconds until your butter is a spreadable consistency.

Tips For Best Air Fryer Results

How to make Air Fryer Grilled Cheese

Preheating Dont skip this step! Most air fryers require a preheating time and it is recommended for best results when cooking your food.

Plenty of space You may be tempted to pack as much food as possible in, but dont overcrowd your air fryer basket or racks. The air fryers need room to circulate air around your sandwiches to get them toasty and melty.

Variable cooking times Since not all air fryers are the same, you may need to watch your food closely toward the end of the cooking cycle. Your sandwiches may cook quickly, or need a minute or two extra depending on your air fryer model.

Don’t Miss: How To Grill Pork Tenderloin

How To Make Grilled Cheese In The Air Fryer

  • Preheat your air fryer to 400°F.
  • Spread butter on one side of each slice of bread.
  • Place the cheese on the unbuttered side, and top with another slice of buttered bread, butter side out.
  • Place on the rack in your air fryer. Cook for 4-5 minutes, flip, and continue cook for 4-5 minutes, or until golden brown.
  • Enjoy! Serve your grilled cheese sandwiches with homemade Instant Pot tomato soup;for a classic meal. Grilled cheese sandwiches are perfect with homemade vegetable soup, too. Keep things simple and serve your sandwiches with refrigerator dill pickles or homemade sweet potato chips that you make in a microwave oven.;

How To Make Grilled Cheese In An Air Fryer Oven

  • Butter the outside of bread slices. Fill with desired amount of cheese slices.
  • Grease air fryer basket then place prepared sandwich in basket.
  • Air fry at 400ºF for 3 minutes. Flip sandwich and air fry at 400ºF for 3 more minutes. Repeat until sandwich is golden brown and crisp on the outside.
  • What Can You Add To Your Grilled Cheese

    For extra flavor add a pinch of spices to the butter. I like Cajun seasoning for a little spice.

    Add veggies like spinach, arugula, sautéed mushrooms, sautéed onions or finely chopped broccoli florets.

    Tomato and bacon will make this the ultimate grilled cheese.

    Recommended Reading: How To Grill Bacon Wrapped Scallops

    Grilled Cheese In Air Fryer

    Youre probably familiar with the classic way of making a grilled cheese sandwich in a skillet on the stovetop. But what If I told you that you can make this classic sandwich in your air fryer? No joking!

    I am obsessed with my air fryer. I use it for everything these days including making these tasty, quick, and easy Grilled Cheese Sandwiches for lunch!

    This recipe will work in any brand of air fryer. I have the Philips XXL. Be sure to read the hand book that comes with your appliance to familiarize yourself with how it works. Regardless of which brand and model you use, always make sure to follow the manufacturers instructions.

    The best part of the grilled cheese is the crispy cheesy bits that come out the sides of the sandwich, so good! The air fryer toasts it up perfectly.

    Gather Up The Ingredients To Prepare Air Fryer Grilled Cheese

    Making Grilled Cheese in an Air Fryer

    This recipe keeps it sweet and simple, or rather salty, cheesy, and simple. As a matter of fact, it only takes two minutes to prepare and 10 minutes in the air fryer. How perfect is that? You’ll have lunch on the table in just about no time at all. To make two sandwiches, grab four slices of white bread, a couple tablespoons of butter, and 1 cup of shredded mild cheddar cheese. That’s it!

    If you’re not a fan of white bread, you can honestly use whatever thinner, flatter bread you’d like, such a whole wheat, sourdough, or even gluten-free. As far as the butter’s concerned, there are so many options available, but Olayinka prefers organic and lightly salted. ” the best,” she notes.

    You May Like: What Temp Do I Grill Steak

    Common Grilled Cheese Questions:

    What type of cheese should I use in a grilled cheese?

    Honestly, any cheese will work, even cream cheese! The classic grilled cheese calls for 2 slices of American cheese, but you can replace that with whatever sliced cheese you have on hand. Cheddar, havarti, and pepperjack are personal favorites of ours.

    Which bread is the best for making a grilled cheese?

    We usually have white sandwich bread on hand, but wheat also works well. French bread or any artisan bread will also work. Use what you like!

    What can I use in place of butter?

    Believe it or not, mayo makes a great grilled cheese! Slather the outside with mayo instead of butter and your sandwich will crisp up perfectly.

    What should I serve with my grilled cheese?

    Soup, chili, french fries, chips, and a side of ranch dressing to dip it in! There really is no wrong answer when it comes to grilled cheeseit goes great with anything!

    Why Use An Air Fryer For Grilled Cheese

    Olayinka explains that she’s “literally on the hunt” to uncover what she can and cannot air fry. Her mission to tackle as many recipes as possible with an air fryer led her to the epitome of the classic grilled cheese sandwich. “I had to do the air fryer grilled cheese,” she exclaims. The beauty of the air fryer with this dish is that is crisps up the outside of the bread slices without torching them and melts the cheese perfectly. It seriously is a fantastic recipe to try in the air fryer and will soon become a new go-to in your home.

    Also Check: What To Put On Salmon To Grill

    Some Essential Tips For Making The Best

    You should remember that no matter what dish you prepare, it should look best and taste best, as well. That means you should never consider anything with the food quality. You may follow these mentioned-below tips to make the preferred grilled-cheese every time.

    • Bread: Try to choose high-quality bread. As you know, bread plays a crucial role in making the grilled cheese perfect.
    • Butter: Likewise, the bread, select the best quality butter and apply it generously on the breads outer sides.
    • Spillage Protection: You need to ensure that the cheese remains stable on the bread slice. It shouldnt come out and leak over the breads edges.
    • Perfect Sandwich: You need to pin the sandwich using toothpicks. It will withstand the bread from flying off.

    Air Fryer Grilled Ham And Cheese

    How to Make The Best Grilled Cheese in an Air Fryer

    These easy Air Fryer Grilled Ham and Cheese sandwiches are a perfectly crispy way to enjoy the classic combination of ham and cheese! Stack your sandwiches with slices of ham and your favorite cheese and get ready to enjoy melted cheesy goodness in just minutes!

    Delightfully crispy, cheesy grilled ham and cheese sandwiches are super easy to make in your air fryer!

    Recommended Reading: How Long Do Gas Grills Last

    How To Prepare Grilled Cheese In An Air Fryer Oven

    Before moving onto cooking, first, lets make a list of the ingredients:

    • Bread: Some people prefer using regular bread, while others go with sourdough bread. Both bread types are good to go; you can use one type that suits you most.
    • Cheese: It is the primary ingredient for making grilled cheese. You can use various types of cheeses, including melty, American, cheddar, Gouda, etc. No matter which cheese you select, make sure you have the best one.
    • Mayo: Although it isnt mandatory, you can use mayonnaise as an additional ingredient.
    • Butter: Butter will add flavor to your grilled cheese, so you shouldnt skip this item.

    Now, you may think about why you should use both mayonnaise and butter in your dish. Even it may sound crazy! Well, if you use mayonnaise and butter and spread them on your bread, your grilled cheese will taste absolutely divine. If you havent ever tried it, you must follow the recipe and try it.

    Apart from that, there are some more reasons for using mayonnaise on the grilled cheese, and these are: mayonnaise requires more time to get smoky, which means your bread gets enough time to get the golden texture.

    Alongside the bread, cheese also gets adequate time to melt. Thanks to mayonnaise, your bread achieves a golden and crunchy texture and fluffy melty interior.

    When you add butter besides mayonnaise, you create the perfect topping. Adding butter gives the best flavor that you desire. Thus, both are essential ingredients to add to your grilled cheese.

    Air Fryer Grilled Cheese Recipe

    • white bread, or bread of your choice personally, I love the classic white bread when it comes to this recipe, but feel free to use whatever bread you have on hand or whatever you prefer.
    • butter or mayonnaise I use either or, depending on my mood. However, when I want the brownest, crispiest, and most flavorful sandwich, I go with mayo.
    • American cheese any melty cheese is good for this recipe, but American cheese is the classic we all know and love!

    Recommended Reading: Where To Buy Propane Gas For Grill

    Air Fryer Grilled Ham And Cheese Sandwich Recipe

    There’s always a debate in our house about which is better, the simple grilled cheese sandwich, or a meatier version. Since I am the only real fan of ham in the household, I’ll let the others pick their own favorites. I already know that if there’s ham in the refrigerator, I’ll be adding it!

    Thin deli-sliced ham is best folded over, but I truly love thick slices of leftover holiday ham best! The flavor from the roasted ham adds so much to an already fabulous sandwich!

    More to the point, the air fryer version of these comfort food sandwiches is a true delight! No more not-quite-melted cheese in the center, or having to use American cheese for an easy solution to perfectly melted cheese.

    Popular Articles

    More Recipes Like This