Gas Or Charcoal: What Are The Differences
If you face the choice of whether to buy a gas grill or a charcoal grill, you have to differentiate them. In what areas do they differ? How does charcoal-grilled food taste compared to the food prepared with a gas grill? In this section, we will enumerate the areas where these two grills differ and discuss them further.
|Emits twice as much carbon dioxide as the gas grill|
Do Gas Grills Need Charcoal
Gas grills can cook the food through the heat produced by the burners. They are designed this way and dont require charcoals. It is something to think about when choosing between the two grills.
A standard gas grill doesnt work with charcoal. It other words, you cant add coals onto the heat up burners. Otherwise, the charcoal and ashes will get into the gas grill that can turn up into a messy cooking space. Also, it is not safe to have burning coal falling out of the grill.
The best reason why you shouldnt use charcoal on gas grills is that it may damage the parts of the gas grills. Users who did it reported broken components that they had to replace. However, there are the latest gas grill models that work with charcoal as a secondary fuel source. They come at a higher price but are worth it if you consider cooking to come up with the best results.
Direct Or Indirect Cooking With Charcoal Grills
Charcoal grills are great for both direct and indirect heat. As previously mentioned, direct heat is what most people would consider normal grilling, and charcoal performs the job exceptionally well. What makes charcoal grills different is their ability to utilize indirect cooking methods, as well.
Most common charcoal grill models, such as kettle grills, can have lit charcoal on one side of the grill while placing food on the other side. We cover this in more detail in this guide. if youre interested in learning about how this process works on a charcoal grill, but the short explanation is this allows for a different cooking style, and therefore, different recipe options.
If youre looking to take your grilling game up another level still, charcoal grills also include smokers. These are true indirect heat machines which are excellent for creating traditional pit-style barbecue right in your own backyard. You can find out more in our smoker buying guide.
Read Also: How Do You Grill Zucchini On The Grill
Charcoal Vs Gas Grills: Which Is Better
Did you know that seven out of ten adults in the United States of America own a grill or smoker of some sort? There arent many meals that are better than meat fresh off of the best grills.
When youre looking to buy grills for the first time, it is important that you know your options. The biggest competition between different types of grills is charcoal vs gas grills. Each type has its benefits and is popular for a reason.
The good news is that if youre looking for a place to learn more about the differences between charcoal grills and gas grills then youve come to the right place. Continue reading to learn more about both types of grills and why they might be right for you.
How Do Charcoal Grills Work?
All grills work in a similar fashion, but they can get heat from different sources. When it comes to charcoal grills, youre going to need either lumps of charcoal or briquette in the grate of the grill in order to produce the heat necessary for cooking the meat and food of your choice.
Once youve got the charcoal lit, youll use the air vents at the top and bottom of the grill as a way of controlling the amount of heat. People who love charcoal grills tend to prefer them because they believe that it gives the meat a different flavor when compared to other types of grills like gas grills.
Pros of Charcoal Grills
Cons of Charcoal Grills
How Do Gas Grills Work?
Pros of Gas Grills
Cons of Gas Grills
Now You Know the Difference Between Charcoal vs Gas Grills
Heat Management: The Lids Ain’t The Same
One thing that folks who cook regularly on both gas and charcoal may notice: Optimal lid configuration for cooking differs depending on the heat source. With a charcoal grill, closing the lid will cut oxygen flow, effectively stifling the flame and lowering your heat flux, while leaving it open will maximize oxygen flow to your fuel and thus get it to burn hotter. With a gas grill, the exact opposite happens: Closing the lid will not affect the rate at which your gas flame burns, but it will prevent excess heat from escaping into the atmosphere, making the grill hotter. For this reason, gas grills with stainless steel construction and internal heat deflectors also work more efficiently than single-walled grills with aluminum construction.
This makes a big difference when you’re trying to sear a piece of meat. For the best sear on a charcoal grill, after preheating, remove the lid and let the coals really get going before you place your meat over them. With a gas grill, close the cover and let the air and grill bars get ripping hot until just before you add your meat.
Beyond cosmetics, why does this matter ? With more areas exposed to high heat, you get more browning and crusting on a charcoal grill, which in turn leads to better flavor and texture. However, some modern gas grills do have “infrared” cooking zones, which are designed to behave more like a coal grill’s radiant heat. Your mileage on their effectiveness will vary by brand.
Long story short:
Don’t Miss: What Model Weber Grill Do I Have
Charcoal Vs Gas Grill And Beyond: Your Guide To Different Types Of Grills
Hard wood pellet grills, propane gas burners, to charcoal kettles, picking the right backyard cooker for your needs isn’t easy. We break it all down so shopping for one is easy.
If not, maybe you should consider buying a new grill. The landscape is constantly changing though, and the great debate over which type of grill is better has only grown more complex with more options. It’s no longer just about charcoal vs. gas.
Get the CNET Home newsletter
If you have little grill knowledge or are in the market to replace your worn out one with a shiny new barbecue grill, here are the five main types of grills you can choose from.
Unless you use a torch or electric starter, charcoal grills take time to light.
A classic and favorite among purists, the charcoal grill is often heralded as a superior or more authentic way to grill food. Though they come in all shapes and sizes, they all use charcoal briquettes or lump charcoal as a fuel source, which produces a distinct, strong and smoky flavor.
Charcoal grills are usually pretty affordable, starting as little as $30 and going up to $300. They also come in a bevy of different styles:
Gas Vs Charcoal For Health
For those who simply want the healthier option, you should choose gas. Well get into how to make charcoal grilling healthier below, but its important to first understand why charcoal is the less healthy option. When you cook on a charcoal grill, it releases two types of molecules into your meats and veggies: heterocyclic amines and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons . How does that happen? When the fat drips down into the fire, the HCAs and PAHs bind to the smoke and fuse into your meat.
What is so bad about HCAs and PAHs? Well, they are known to increase your risk for cancer. Supporting studies have been conducted in well-known circles in the scientific community, such as the American Journal of Epidemiology. These PAHs and HCAs have been linked to skin, lung, prostate, rectal, breast, and pancreatic cancer cells.
Keep in mind though that as with any other behavior, these risks are cumulative over ones lifetime. Eating a couple of meals cooked over charcoal in and of itself wont cause cancer overnight and its worth mentioning that youre still avoiding the added fats that would be used to fry, or saute your food.
Read Also: How To Grill Boneless Chicken Breast
Cons Of Electric Grills
As you may have figured out, electric grills do have some cons to them:
- Need an outlet to supply them with electricity
- Only work when electricity is available
- Do not supply food with any additional, interesting flavors
- Can be expensive to buy initially and to run on a regular basis
- If liquid hits the electric grill, it can short-circuit the entire unit
Best Entry Level Gas Grill Weber Spirit Ii E
The Weber Spirit is the entry level Weber gas grill. It still has great features like side tables, lots of cooking area, and an open cooking cart. There is a two burner unit available for less money, but I feel strongly that three burners are a much better choice. There are definitely grills available for less money, but if you want a grill to last, get a Weber!
Recommended Reading: Char Griller Akorn Jr Review
Cons Of Pellet Grills
Nevertheless, pellet grills do have a few cons that you should keep in mind before investing in a pellet vs. charcoal smoker:
- More expensive than charcoal grills
- Slightly higher fuel costs
- Some people are not happy with how hot pellet grills get, as they cant achieve the higher temperatures achieved by most charcoal grills, particularly kamados, which can make searing less effective without special attachments or additional features on the grill
- Require electricity to use
Pellet Grill Vs Electric Grill
Electric grills are somewhat different than other types of grills because they need to be plugged in to work. However, this can make them a viable choice for people who live in apartments and cant have gas or charcoal grills on their back decks or patios. In fact, some electric grills are so small that they can be used in an enclosed kitchen.
With that being said, electric grills are not necessarily right for all occasions or buyers who want to grill food. Check out the pros and cons of electric grills vs. pellet grills below.
You May Like: How Long Does Lobster Take To Grill
Charcoal Vs Gas Grill: Which Is Best For You
Grill season is in full swing. If youre hoping to entertain in your backyard and host the biggest barbecues on the block, you need to make sure your grill is fired up and ready to go. But this obviously prompts the age-old question: should you go gas or charcoal for your grilling needs?
Grill masters the world over have wrestled with this question, and everyone seems to have their own answer based on their family recipes, the foods they tend to grill the most, their most valued experts advice, and good old-fashioned intuition. Today, we will talk you through the pros and cons of charcoal and gas grills, so you can decide which is best for you.
Get everything you need for your next cookout at Grayco Hardware & Home Center. Find my Grayco.
Grill At Lower Temperatures And Dont Char Meat
High temperatures cause charring and HCAs. Grilling at lower temperatures may reduce this risk. You can use a lower flame to keep the temperature and smoking low. You can also move your coals to the side but keep your meat in the middle of the grill. It might take longer to cook this way, but if you keep temperatures low, youll cut down on the formation of carcinogens.
If any pieces of your meat do char, its best to discard those parts. The charred bits contain the most HCAs. So its a good idea to cut the burned and charred parts off any meat before you serve it.
Also Check: Super Smoke Mode Traeger
Pellet Grill Vs Gas Grill
Gas grills are extremely popular, especially if you walk into your local big box store. There are all the brand names youve come to expect, you can get as few or as many square inches of cooking space that youd like, and the prices can range as high or low as youre willing to go. Gas grills often time come with some cool features as well, like side burners that run off of the fuel tank.
If youve been a Grilla Grills fan for a while, youll know that we offer a gas grill we call the Primate. It includes many of the above-mentioned features, in addition to offering a superb griddle surface. So its safe to say that we know and appreciate gas grills just as much as we do pellet varieties.
While gas grills are the most popular grills on the market there are some very clear positives and negatives in choosing a gas grill.
Gas Or Charcoal: The Debate Rages On
Few topics in life inspire such passionate debate as politics, religion, andevidentlywhether gas or charcoal grilling is better. In some parts of the U.S., barbecuing is kin to mysticism. What is the true nature of barbecue sauce? Which ingredient unlocks the secret flavor? How does smoke enhance the savory experience?
At Weber, weve heard it all. So, at the risk of offending the devout, we offer our insights into the great debate. Basically, were non-partisan. Any grilling is good grilling if it suits your needs and tastes.
We recommend the method that fits your lifestyle. Some folks feel a basic human need to make fire they enjoy the hands-on experience of lighting charcoal. Some even like a challenge of charcoal grilling in cold, wet or windy weather.
Waiting for the charcoal to reach cooking temperature is half the fun for these folks . And the portability of the smaller grill is a must for grillers on the go.
Other folks want convenience and spontaneity. A gas grill allows them to instantly fire it up anytime and get down to cooking. Adjusting temperatures is as easy as turning a knob. Gas grills are inexpensive to operate, offer easy cleanup and offer no resistance in inclement weather.
But what about flavor?
Read Also: Coleman Road Trip Pro Grill
Which Is Better Charcoal Or Gas Grills
There is plenty of speculation on the subject of which is better charcoal or gas grills. Each grill has its unique qualities and its ups and downs for certain factors.
But the simple question exists when buying a new grill, which type of grill is better? Charcoal grills vs gas grills will always be a hot topic in the grilling world, and really when it comes down to an answer, it is all about personal preference.
But they are two different types of grills that are vastly different and can achieve some very different results when used correctly. Keep reading the article to learn the differences between gas and charcoal grills and which one may be the best fit for you.
Note: most links in this article are Amazon.com Affiliate links, see Affiliate Disclosure, thank you.
Gas Barbecue Prices And Brands
Price is no guarantee of quality, which is why our barbecue reviews are the best place to find out just how good a barbecue is. You could pay less than £50 or well into four figures for a gas grill.
In general, the more expensive a gas barbecue is, the more features you get.
To make sure you buy from a brand that is reliable and wont need replacing too soon, check out our barbecue brands guide. We routinely survey consumers about the barbecues they own and the problems theyve faced with them, so you can make sure to get a barbecue that can be relied on.
Also Check: Stainless Steel Cleaner For Grills
The Negatives Of A Charcoal Barbecue
Heat control is more of a struggle with live fire and itll take some care, intuition and plenty of practice. With time, youll be able to cook almost anything thanks to the radiant, high heat that charcoal provides.
The charcoal itself doesnt actually provide much in the way of extra smokiness with the flavour in both cases coming from the drippings hitting the heat source and smoking up over the food. However, you could argue that the area of heat is larger with coal, providing more space for dripping.
Charcoal grills can be slightly restrictive in size. They can have smaller cooking areas and often no cooling shelves. Mix this with the slightly lengthier start time and tricky heat regulation , and youll soon notice youre spending more time managing the cook, rather than relaxing with your guests.
So Gas Or Charcoal Grills
Ideally, you could install both charcoal and gas grills in your outdoor kitchen, since both have their distinct advantages and would complement each other well. Even within those two categories, there are many more variations to consider . At the end of the day, the best grill for you will be entirely dependent on how you plan to use it, so use the considerations above to make your decision.
Still, having trouble deciding? Our grilling specialists can assist you further. To speak with a member of our team, contact us by email or phone and well do our best to help you find the right product for your space, cooking style and budget.
Also Check: How To Clean Traeger Grill
Pellet Grill Vs Charcoal Grill
For years the charcoal grill was the standard for the home cooking grilling aficionado. Many purists claim that the flavor imparted from charcoal is the only way to grill. While many people are familiar with charcoal grills, its worth noting that charcoal grills come in many shapes and sizes. Here are some of the more popular styles of charcoal grills:
- Kettle grills are what most people think of when they think of a charcoal grill, with a round grill set atop a tripod with a lid and a vent. Kettle grills are often a popular choice as a portable grill as there are many smaller, lightweight models available for camping or traveling.
- Barrel grills are what they sound like, grills that are made out of barrels, or to look like traditional 55-gallon barrels, cut in half with a hinge and some legs to stand on.
- Cart grills are basically grills that look like modern gas grills but use charcoal for fuel.
- Kamado grills are egg-shaped grills made out of ceramic. The ceramic material provides insulation which helps create an even cooking temperature across the entire cooking area. Kamados can also achieve grill temperatures of 700 degrees or more, which makes them great for searing or using them as a pizza oven. These grills have become very popular among home chefs, and if youd like to check one out have a look at Grillas Kong ceramic kamado grill.