How To Make Grilled Cheese Better

Can You Scrape Off Burnt Toast

How to Make a Better Grilled Cheese

Your toast has a layer of black, but beneath it, youre convinced youll find a perfect shade of golden brown. So grab a four-sided cheese grater, says Baldini, and a bowl. In a gentle, circular motion, rub the blackened side of the toast across the grater and let the burned pieces fall into a bowl.

Ways To Make Your Grilled Cheese Better Than Anyone Else’s

Theres more to grilled cheese than just bread and cheese.

Get the right bread. Almost any bread can work for a grilled cheese, but start out with bread that complements the remaining ingredients and doesnt have too many holes. If youre going for a sweet chèvre and jam grilled cheese, go for a few slices of country bread.

Step outside of your cheese comfort zone. Not that theres anything wrong with slices of American cheese product, but sample different options like Havarti, Brie, and even manchego.

Choose cheese that will melt. Hard cheese , most fresh crumbly cheese , and other kinds of cheese just refuse to melt. Pro tip: grated cheese melts faster and more evenly than slices of cheese.

The Best Grilled Cheese Sandwich

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclosure policy.

Nothing is more comforting than a hot, melty grilled cheese sandwich. Grilled cheese and tomato soup are a combo made in heaven. Its the perfect easy lunch recipe and great for even the pickiest of eaters.

The best grilled cheese always starts with a sturdy bread, lots of cheese and a smear of butter mayonnaise on the outside!

Also Check: Is Macaroni Grill Still In Business

Keep Things Low And Slow


Youre not searing steaks here: grilled cheese should be cooked slowly at low temperatures so that they get evenly heated, right down to the core. By keeping your stoves flame just above its lowest setting for a longer period of time, youre not only more likely to get a completely melted layer of cheese, but youll also avoid charring the bread until its black.

Low heat especially helps with thicker sandwiches that take longer to heat through, like these hefty grilled cheeses with massive chunks of juicy Buffalo chicken . Get our Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese recipe.

How To Make Grilled Cheese

How to Make Grilled Cheese

Anyone can make an OK grilled cheese. But we want you to know how to make the BEST grilled cheese sandwich. As ever, its all about technique. Our grilled cheese recipe relies on a few key things:

  • Low heat. You cant rush a great grilled cheese. Low heat allows the bread to toast slowly while the cheese melts.
  • Butter AND mayo. Yes, were saying you need to make your grilled cheese with mayo! This is not the moment to skimp, friends! Any way you slice itwere diagonal people, ourselvesgrilled cheese is an indulgence. Just go ahead and go big! Make it perfect and enjoy.
  • Shredded cheese. Shredded cheese will melt more quickly and evenly than sliced, so its perfect for making a grilled cheese sandwich.
  • White bread. Classic, simple, and a great toaster. Its also really good at soaking up all of that melty butter and creamy mayo.

You May Like: Char Broil Infrared Grill Cleaning

Best Grilled Cheese Recipe

When done correctly, a classic grilled cheese sandwich has the perfect contrast between crunchy bread exterior and creamy melted cheese filling. Its one of those fast and easy meals to serve picky eaters. But when paired with a big bowl of tomato soup, its the ultimate adult comfort food.

To satisfy our immediate cravings, the misconception is to crank up the heat and get the cheese melted fast! However, its quite the opposite. To make sure the bread gets evenly toasted and the middle completely gooey, patience and low heat is the answer. Melted butter also helps with crispness, but not too much otherwise youll get greasy results. Ready to go over the science behind making this well-loved sandwich at home?

Pick A Healthier Bread

The traditional white bread used to craft grilled cheese sandwiches lacks fiber and can taste a little bland. For a healthier substitute, choose a whole grain bread.

Whole grain breads include the bran, endosperm, and germ, so you get extra nutrients from the wheat. Some multigrain bread also include seeds, such as sunflower seeds and flaxseeds.

The whole grains and seeds give a nuttier flavor and heartier texture but they also deliver added fiber.

Also Check: How To Grill Burgers On Propane Grill

Add Color And Flavor With Plant

Enhance your grilled cheese sandwich by adding fruits and vegetables of various colors. The addition of these plant foods will boost the color appeal and nutritional content of your sandwich.

Experiment with fruits and vegetables by throwing in some apples, avocados, zucchini, eggplant, tomatoes, spinach, onions, or peppers. For more fun flavors, add herbs like basil leaves, chives, or parsley.

Make The Switch To A Healthier Fat

How to Make Grilled Cheese Sandwich in a Frying Pan | Taste Better by Lounging with Lenny

Slapping a hunk of butter in your pan or slathering your bread with mayo are common ways to prepare grilled cheese. Lots of butter and mayo adds extra calories and saturated fat.

To lower your saturated fat intake, try using avocado oil or olive oil in your pan instead of butter.


Grilled cheese can be made a little bit healthier. Start with fiber-rich whole grain bread, choose flavorful cheese, try some plant-based toppings, and use a healthy fat when cooking.

Also Check: Macaroni Grill Chain

Peanut Butter Is One Shocking Ingredient That Can Make For A Delicious Grilled Cheese Sandwich

In her book “Grilled Cheese, Please,” Laura Werlin gives a recipe for a grilled cheese sandwich with whole wheat bread, peanut butter, bologna slices, cheese, and dill pickles. Though this might sound disgusting, she explains that, somehow, the flavors all come together.

“I cook those bologna slices a little bit to get them crispy and put a little mayonnaise on the outside,” she told Insider. “It sounds weird, but it’s honestly really good.”

Perfect Cast Iron Grilled Cheese

A grilled cheese sandwich is only as good as its ingredients: tangy sourdough bread, a blend of high-quality cheeses, and plenty of Challenge Butter slathered on each side. For this recipe, we recommend a cast-iron pan for its even distribution of heat we also suggest a variety of filling options, depending on your mood or what you have on hand.

Recommended Reading: How To Convert Gas Grill To Natural Gas

How To Make The Best Grilled Cheese Sandwich

The grilled cheese plays varied roles in our livesit may be the lunchtime diner order: two slices of white bread with gooey American cheese. It may be the late-night snack: leftover whole wheat with slices of Swiss eaten after a stressful day, à la The Devil Wears Prada. And, more and more often, it maybe be gourmet: great artisan bread, imported cheese, and fresh vegetables.

Thats the situation here. We matched slices of sourdough bread with Danish fontina cheese, which melts into an extraordinarily gooey filling. Weve also stuffed summer heirloom tomatoes, spicy leaves of rocket, and rings of red onion in between the bread.

Delicious as they are, the ingredients arent everything in a grilled cheese. Theres technique too. Youve got to get the bread crispy at the same rate as the cheese melts. Youve got to use enough fatbutter or olive oilin the pan so that the bread gets really golden. Below, were rounded up our tips for making great grilled cheese sandwiches. As if that werent enough, we asked our for their tips on crafting the perfect grilled cheese. Read on to become a sandwich pro!

The Best Tip For A Perfect Grilled Cheese

How to Make Grilled Cheese

My friends, this is a must. I make grilled cheese without butter! Swap out the butter on the outside of the sandwich for mayonnaise. Cook mayonnaise side down in the pan.

Your grilled cheese will come out perfectly golden with a crust that doesnt get soggy and is not greasy!

If the pan is too hot, the cheese wont melt before the outside is cooked. If you notice the cheese taking awhile, cover it with a lid. The steam will help melt the cheese so it cooks evenly!

Also Check: Weber Grill Grates Rusting

Tips For The Best Grilled Cheese

  • Low heat it takes a little patience to make the perfect grilled cheese. Keep your heat on low to give the cheese time to fully melt while the bread gets golden and crisp. If browning too fast, turn the heat down.
  • Butter generously the amount of butter may seem like a lot, but it is important for a crispy exterior.
  • Use thick-sliced bread we love using Texas toast because its sliced about twice as thick as normal sandwich bread. You want bread that is about 3/4 to 1 thick, but also avoid bread that is too thick or your cheese wont melt properly. Using bread that is too thin will produce a flimsy and sometimes soggy sandwich.

Be Choosy With Cheese

Choosing flavorful cheeses like Gruyère, sharp cheddar, Gouda, and havarti bring a richer, distinct flavor to your grilled cheese. You also may find yourself using less cheese, since their flavors are bolder than that of American cheese.

Using less cheese means fewer calories for your sandwich, but it doesnt mean you have to lose that cheesy goodness and flavor.

Don’t Miss: Do Traeger Grills Need Electricity

Ways To Make Grilled Cheese Sandwiches Even Better Using Things You Have In Your Kitchen

Grilled cheese sandwiches are easy-to-make and delicious, no matter what ingredients you have laying around.

However, if you really want to take your grilled cheeses to the next level, you shouldn’t be afraid to experiment by adding interesting ingredients like pickles, tomatoes, and even peanut butter.

“With grilled cheese sandwiches, the world is your oyster,” Laura Werlin, the author of “Grilled Cheese, Please” and “Great Grilled Cheese” told Insider. “You can put almost anything you like in between two slices of bread with cheese and grill it. However, it’s called a grilled cheese for a reason – you still want the cheese to be the star.”

“With grilled cheese sandwiches, it’s a canvas,” Heidi Gibson, the co-owner of American Grilled Cheese Kitchen in San Francisco, co-author of “Grilled Cheese Kitchen: Bread + Cheese + Everything in Between,” and winner of multiple grilled cheese competitions, told Insider. “There’s a lot of flexibility there. For me, that’s part of the fun. How can I make a grilled cheese sandwich into something extraordinary with these humble beginnings?”

Meaty Grilled Cheese Sandwiches:

Thereâs a Better Way To Make a Grilled Cheese

Prepare as directed, except place a thin layer thinly sliced cooked ham, roast beef, pepperoni, salami, or shredded cooked chicken or turkey on the cheese before topping with the remaining bread slices.

Per sandwich: 357 cal., 14 g pro., 28 g carb., 22 g total fat , 54 mg chol., 2 g fiber, 867 mg sodium

Read Also: How To Clean Char Broil Infrared Grill Grates

Can You Use Pam To Make Grilled Cheese

Forget about all that fatty butter and margarine, making grilled cheese sandwiches with PAM is faster, healthier and delicious. Set your skillet to medium and spray one side of a slice of bread with PAM cooking spray. Place the sprayed side of your bread face down in the pan and place a slice of cheese on top of it.

How To Make A Better Grilled Cheese Sandwich

The best of comfort food is elevated in this recipe with an umami-rich Japanese mayonnaise.

The following excerpt is reprinted from Milk Bar Life: Recipes and Stories by Christina Tosi with photos by Gabriele Stabile and Mark Ibold. Published by Clarkson Potter/Publishers, an imprint of Penguin Random House LLC.

Paul Carmichael is the chef de cuisine at Má Pêche, the Momofuku outpost in Midtown Manhattan that also houses a Milk Bar. Many moons ago, when we were both cooks at wd-50, he made the most delicious grilled cheese sandwiches for family meal. I talked about them for years, though he swears theres nothing fancy about it at all.

While we were putting this book together, I finally convinced him to hand over his recipe so we could make them for ourselves. Thats when we discovered the secret to his perfect grilled cheese: Kewpie mayonnaise. This realization confirmed what we already knew, Kewpie is the secret to any good recipe with mayonnaise as an ingredient.

Recommended Reading: Should The Grill Be Open Or Closed

How Much Cheese To Use

I find that using at least 2 thick slices, about to ¼-inch max, of sharp cheddar provides just the right ratio of cheese-to-bread. If the slices are any thicker, itll affect the melt time. If using a block of cheese, you can grate or shred it to make an even layer, although it will melt quicker than slices.

When placing the cheese on top of the unbuttered side of the bread, leave a little bit of space along the edges so the cheese doesnt spew over, unless you like a little bit of fried cheese on the edges.

How To Make The Perfect Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Maple Grilled Cheese from How to Make the Perfect Grilled ...

Fluffy Mighty White or the fuller texture of artisan sourdough? Taleggio, Teifi or prepacked slices? And what is the best way to cook your sandwich: grill, griddle, frying pan or toastie machine?

Before you dive below the line to scoff at the cheek of publishing a recipe for something as basic as a simple cheese toastie, consider this. Any idiot with a frying pan can make a grilled cheese sandwich but how many are worthy of the enormous calorie load they pack? This is one recipe that deserves to be perfect after all, if you eat too many of the things, life really will be too short to bother with a bad cheese sandwich.

For a start, as the good people of Twitter kindly inform me, the relationship between a cheese toastie and a grilled cheese sandwich is analogous, as Id assumed, to that between macaroni cheese and mac and cheese the latter being the bigger, brasher American version of our own, humbler family favourite. No, as Lynne Clark of the Greedy Piglet blog informed me, a grilled cheese sandwich is buttered on the outside and cooked in a pan, and the toastie is buttered on the inside and, well, toasted. As I dont own any variety of sandwich toaster for the sake of my health, this piece will concentrate on the fried variety .

You May Like: Grease Stains On Pavers

Dont Skimp On The Butter

You need enough butter to achieve the crackly-crisp, buttery, golden exterior that we all crave. If you always keep a stick of butter on the counter, you can simply spread the softened butter generously over the outside pieces of bread. If you dont , you can melt a pat of butter in the skillet before you add the bread.

What Pan To Use

I prefer to use my cast iron skillet as it maintains a consistent heat better and gives a superior crispy surface. A nonstick skillet works well and prevents sticking if using sweeter types of bread. In either case, you want to use very moderate heat for making the sandwiches, about medium-low or low if the bread is toasting too quickly.

Read Also: How To Grill Ribeye Steak

Pantry Staples Like Tomato Or Bacon Jams Are Delicious In Grilled Cheese

Many people might have jams floating around in their pantries without knowing how to utilize them. To add a ton of flavor to a simple grilled cheese, adding ingredients like chutney, pepper jelly, tomato jam, or bacon jam can totally change the flavor profile.

“Any jam, any chutney, even dijon mustard, almost any condiment will lend itself to a grilled cheese sandwich,” Werlin said.

“If you’ve got sweet or savory condiments like pepper jelly or onion relish sitting in the back of your fridge, those work great in a grilled cheese,” Gibson said.

Roasted Or Sauteed Peppers Also Add A Lot Of Flavor And Texture To Grilled Cheese Sandwiches

How to make healthier Grilled Cheese

Bell peppers can be used in a number of different recipes, so they’ll never go to waste in your fridge. However, if you’re using them in a grilled cheese sandwich, Laura Werlin recommends cooking them a little bit before adding them.

“Bell peppers should be a little bit softer when you put them in, so you might want to roast them,” she said.

“The key with vegetables is getting the water out, otherwise you end up with a watery grilled cheese,” Heidi Gibson told Insider.

Read Also: How To Grill Bone In Pork Chops

How To Make The Best Grilled Cheese Sandwiches

We reveal the best cheeses for grilled cheese along with additional tips for creating the best grilled cheese sandwiches ever.

Admittedly, there’s as lot going on. So you may have missed the most important scientific discovery of our young century: Science has discovered the best cheeses for making grilled cheese. What are the best cheeses for grilled cheese? We reveal them here, and offer 4 additional tips for making the best grilled cheese sandwiches.

Or Go Healthy Add Fermented Deliciousness

A forkful of pickled peppers, pickled cucumbers, pickled onions, or sauerkraut adds tangy crunch to the inside.

Or slice up an apple and add some fresh thyme. “The apple adds a little crunch and pop of tartness, and the thyme gives it freshness with just a tease of its flavor, just enough to make this sandwich special,” says lutzflcat.

Read Also: How To Clean Traeger Grill

Popular Articles

More Recipes Like This